Kyle Mitchell

We are thrilled to welcome the Mitchell family to Grace Church and DeMotte as Lead Teaching Pastor

Meet Kyle Mitchell

After a season of prayer and discernment, the Pastoral Search Team has unanimously agreed that God is leading Grace Church to invite Kyle to serve as our new Lead Teaching Pastor. Rooted in our commitment to the Gospel and discipleship, we have sought a leader who will faithfully teach Scripture, shepherd with humility, and lead the church on mission. We believe Pastor Kyle embodies this calling.

On Wednesday, March 4th, the Pastoral Search team voted to extend the call to Kyle. He, along with his family and wife Karen, accepted the call on March 9th to become part of our church family.

12 months ago, you entrusted the Search Committee of Grace Church with the responsibility of earnestly and humbly seeking the Lord’s will for the next Lead Teaching Pastor of Grace Church. From the beginning, we have relied on prayer, fasting, Scripture, and the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

After many listening sessions and an extensive interview process involving a broad group of candidates, the Lord brought clarity and unity to our committee. Through this process, the Search Committee unanimously identified the man we believe God is calling to serve as the next Lead Teaching Pastor of Grace Church.

With great joy and gratitude, we present  Kyle Mitchell, current Lead Pastor at  CityWON Church  in Leavenworth, Kansas, to come in View of a Call. Through months of prayerful conversation, we are confident that Pastor Kyle demonstrates the biblical qualifications, spiritual maturity, and leadership skills needed to shepherd our church faithfully into the future.

The Pastoral Search Committee is unanimous in recommending Pastor Kyle as the next Lead Teaching Pastor of Grace Church. We encourage you to join us in prayerful preparation as we seek the Lord together in this important moment in the life of our church.

—The Pastor Search Committee: Anthony Dixon, Matt Miklos, Tim Hester, John Wilkinson, Nick Kotur, Josh Perzee, Mike Defries, and James Stacy

Meet the Mitchells

Kyle and Karen have been married for 23 wonderful years and are the proud parents of three amazing children. Both grew up in the Pacific Northwest, but over time they have come to love the Midwest and now gladly call it their true home. Their family enjoys laughing together, going on adventures, and squeezing as much joy out of life as they can. Karen and the kids are gifted, deeply grounded, and are without question the greatest blessings in Kyle’s life. As a family they genuinely enjoy one another and are deeply grateful for the unity God has given them, sharing a love for Him and for His church.

Kyle 

Kyle has served in pastoral ministry for the past 13 years and brings a diverse background in business, creative work, and the music industry. His first season of college was cut short when his band, Kutless, launched into full-time touring, though he is now nearing completion of his Bachelor’s degree in Theology. In his free time, Kyle enjoys hunting, golfing, eating ice cream, and restoring old Volkswagens.

Karen

Karen

Karen is a school teacher by trade and is beloved by many of her students. Her warmth and steady devotion as a wife and mother bring peace and strength to her family, and she serves others with humility and grace. She loves to travel and has explored many places as both a tourist and a performer. At home, she enjoys curling up with a good book, spending time with her kiddos (and cats), and baking incredible treats.

Genevieve

Genevieve

Genevieve is nineteen years old and works as a nail technician. As a seasoned musical theater performer and long-time worship leader, she loves using her gifts to serve the church and encourage others. Known for her warm, sunny disposition, she enjoys movies, traveling, and especially the beach and tropical places. She is excited to be getting married to Tyrone this summer and is looking forward to the adventures ahead.

Macy

Macy

Macy is a sixteen-year-old sophomore who loves choir, art, and theater and has a growing interest in fishing and golf. She uses her voice in many ways—singing at church, making people laugh, and standing up for what is right and true. Her bedroom is filled with the treasures and trinkets she loves to collect, reflecting the vibrant curiosity and creativity that make Macy uniquely herself.

Brennan

Brennan

Brennan is ten years old and in the fourth grade. Known for his quick wit and sharp sense of humor, he keeps his family laughing and on their toes. His interests range from football and learning about firearms to a growing love for cooking and the arts. With a big heart and a big brain, Brennan brings curiosity, creativity, and plenty of personality to everything he does.

I grew up in a stable and loving home as the middle child in a family that encouraged big personalities and big dreams. My parents had a sincere respect for the Christian faith, though we weren’t deeply connected to a local church during my childhood. Even so, their lives shaped me in profound ways. My mom, who stayed home to raise us, constantly reminded me to believe in myself and pursue the gifts God had given me. My dad modeled something just as powerful—quiet integrity, generosity toward others, and a tireless work ethic. Because of them, my childhood was secure, joyful, and full of opportunity.

Yet even with all those blessings, I could sense that something important was missing. God, in His kindness, used a friendship to begin filling that gap. In middle school I met a friend named Ryan Shrout. We became fast friends, but Ryan had something in his life that I didn’t yet understand—an authentic and growing faith in Jesus. He was relentless, in the best possible way, about inviting me to youth group events, gatherings, and trips. Sometimes I went out of curiosity, sometimes just for the fun of it.

What I discovered surprised me. I had carried many misconceptions about Christianity, imagining it to be restrictive or joyless. Instead, I encountered a community marked by genuine freedom, joy, and creativity. I was especially drawn to the music and the vibrant culture surrounding it. Slowly, God began to dismantle the false ideas I had believed. I realized that following Jesus wasn’t about losing everything that made life vibrant—it was about redeeming it. God wasn’t trying to take away my joy or creativity; He wanted to deepen it and use it for His glory. That realization changed everything.

When I turned sixteen and got my driver’s license, I began driving myself to church on Sunday mornings. My curiosity had grown into a sincere hunger to understand the faith I was beginning to embrace. One Sunday, the gospel was presented with clarity and power, and I knew it was true. That morning I placed my trust fully in Jesus Christ and surrendered my life to Him. From that moment forward, my life began to change quickly. During my junior year of high school I immersed myself in Scripture, church life, and discipleship. By the beginning of my senior year, I sensed something even deeper—a clear and compelling call from God to serve Him in ministry.

After graduation, Ryan and I headed to Bible college together. God used those years to deepen both our friendship and our faith. We studied, served, and pursued the Pastoral calling God had placed on our lives. Along the way, He also used our shared love of music as a ministry platform in ways we could never have anticipated. Since then, the Lord has given me many opportunities and experiences that have shaped me over the past thirteen years of pastoral ministry. Every step has been part of His patient work of preparing and refining me.

Even now, I am continually amazed by the heart of God—His relentless love for people and His desire to rescue and redeem us. I am equally humbled that He chooses to use ordinary people to accomplish His extraordinary purposes. I often feel like a nobody from nowhere, yet God delights in using unlikely instruments for His glory. For that reason, I remain deeply grateful—to the loving parents that raised me, to the friend who refused to stop inviting me, to the pastors who invested in me, to the family that always supports me, and above all, to Jesus Christ who gave His life for mine.

Jesus purchased my life with His own blood, and by His grace I intend to spend every remaining day honoring Him and serving His church until the day He calls me home.

Lead Pastor Verbatim Church | Albany, OR | 2014-2021

Lead Pastor cityWON Church | Leavenworth, KS | 2022-Present

Warner Pacific University
2 Years, Pastoral Ministries
Concordia University
Business Classes
Pastoral Leadership Institute
Seminary Classes
Athey Creek Church
Multi-year pastoral training

Kyle plans to further his education while in this role. 



Dear Grace Church Family,

I am deeply grateful and humbled to write to you for the first time as the newly called Lead Teaching Pastor at Grace Church. My heart is full of thankfulness to the Lord for His guidance, and for the opportunity to join a church family with such a rich history of faithfulness and devotion. From everything I have already seen and heard, you are a body marked by a genuine love for Christ, a commitment to His Word, and a desire to serve one another well. It is truly a joy and privilege to be stepping into this new season with you.

At the same time, I want to express my deep respect and gratitude for Pastor Tim and his lovely wife, Rhonda. For 34 years they have faithfully loved, shepherded, and served this congregation. That kind of faithfulness is to be honored and imitated. The legacy of their ministry is evident in the life of this church, and I know I join you in giving thanks for the countless ways the Lord has used them to build up His people at Grace.

Transitions in church leadership are significant moments. They invite us to reflect on God’s goodness in the past while also looking forward with anticipation to what He will continue to do in the future. My hope and prayer is that together we will continue to grow as a church that treasures the gospel, loves one another deeply, and seeks to make Christ known in our community and beyond.

I am eager to get to know each of you in the season ahead. My prayer is that the Lord will knit our hearts together in unity as we pursue His mission and seek to glorify Him in all that we do. Grace is not just on your sign. It fills the halls of the church and the hearts of the people. And when paired with the Truth of God’s Word, we will become more like Jesus, together, for decades to come.

Thank you for the warm welcome you have already shown. I look forward to serving, learning, and walking alongside you as we trust the Lord together for the bright future of Grace Church.

With gratitude and hope,

Pastor Kyle Mitchell


Frequently Asked Questions

Kyle is planning to start May 1st, pending finding a home in or near Demotte.
Karen and the kids would move out here after the school year ends.

There is not a set date, but it will likely be in May and many times throughout the summer. We will update when we finalize the preaching schedule for the next few sermon series.

Kyle’s ministry journey has traveled a unique road to where he is today. After helping found the Christian rock band Kutless, he then moved into pastoral ministry, leading a church in Albany, Oregon, for 8 years. He has been the Lead Pastor of CityWON church in Leavenworth, Kansas, for the last 4 years.

Kyle and his family will be at worship night on 3.15.26 for a meet and greet from 5-6 pm. Kyle will also be out here many more times, and we will update you with more formal meeting times when we know them.

Continue to pray for Tim and Rhonda as they are moving into a new season of life. Pray for the staff and elder teams as they navigate this transition season. Pray for Kyle and Karen and their family as they move out here and join our community.

After prayer, research, and many interviews, the search team believes that
Kyle best fits the pastoral profile and needs of Grace Church, including:
  • Alignment in doctrine and theology
  • Proven preaching and teaching with a commitment to Scripture
  • Leadership and vision-casting experience
  • Commitment to discipleship, life groups, and evangelism 
  • A strong emphasis on missions

Pastor Tim is still planning to retire sometime this fall in 2026.

Nothing yet. We will do multiple meet and greets, gatherings and celebrations as they move out and get settled in.